Skip to main content

Decision Dialogue

Ninety minutes with the people who own a decision, before the gate.

Big programme decisions get made on a slide and a feeling. A Decision Dialogue puts one decision through the Socratic method with the people who'll own it: the real question, the example behind it, the reasons, the rule you're applying and the principle underneath. You leave with the reasons on one page, the evidence you still need, and what would change your mind. It isn't therapy, coaching or a risk workshop.

£1,800 + VAT, 90 minutes online£2,700 + VAT, half a day in the room£4,800 + VAT, Gate Readiness

Gate Readiness is a Decision Dialogue plus a pre-mortem with the gate's decision-makers, ending with the written record and the evidence still needed.

Or try the free Decision Questions tool on a decision you're facing now.

Anna Bromley facilitating a session

Use it before

Go or no-go

The date is fixed, the defects aren't, and the room is split.

Stop or carry on

Nine months in, twice the budget, and nobody wants to be the one who says it.

Choosing a supplier

The cheaper one scored lower in the demos and the procurement rules say take it.

The integration call

Which system survives, which team moves, and who decides when the sponsors disagree.

What happens in the room

A Socratic Dialogue is shaped like an hourglass: it starts wide, narrows to one concrete example, then widens again to the rules and principles. Ninety minutes is enough for one decision. The record arrives within a day.

  1. 1. 15 min

    The question

    The decision restated as a question, in the singular. The assumptions inside it, named and written up.

  2. 2. 20 min

    The example

    One person's concrete experience that bears on it, in their own words, in the past tense. Not the plan. What happened.

  3. 3. 20 min

    The reasons

    The core statement: when I saw X, I decided Y, because Z. The group tests the because.

  4. 4. 15 min

    The rules

    Would we decide this way every time? What's different now? The rule we're applying, out loud.

  5. 5. 15 min

    The principles

    What we're protecting and what we'd give up for it. The one question to answer first. What would change our mind.

What you leave with

  • The decision restated as the question it really is, with its assumptions named.
  • The reasons on one page: the example, the core statement, the rule, the principle.
  • The evidence you still need before you decide, and who will get it.
  • What would change your mind, written down before the decision is made, so the review later is honest.

Why it works

People decide with emotion and add reasons after. A dialogue grounded in one real example slows that down long enough for the reasons to be examined, by the people who have to live with the result. Decisions that come out of it stand up to scrutiny, because they've already had some.

Anna is a programme director and a trained Socratic Dialogue facilitator who runs dialogues alongside her programme work. The method is the one in her handbook, Time for Transformation.

What the written record looks like

One page, in the group's own words, within a working day. This one is an example with a made-up decision.

Decision record

Example

Go live on 1 March with 40 open defects?

The question
Is the service safe for customers on 1 March with 40 defects still open?
The assumptions
The 40 are minor. Support can absorb the extra calls. Moving the date costs more than a rough launch.
The example
Last spring we launched the customer portal with 25 open defects. Two were in payments, and calls to support doubled for six weeks.
The core statement
When we saw two payment defects reach customers, we decided to fix anything that touches money before go-live, because customers forgive a slow screen but not a wrong bill.
The rule
No defect that touches money or personal data goes live open.
The principle
Customers' trust in our numbers comes before the date.
Evidence still needed
The 40 defects triaged by what they touch, signed off by the product owner by 20 February.
What would change our mind
If the triage shows none of the 40 touches money or personal data, 1 March stands.

Frequently asked questions

Is this a workshop, coaching or training?

None of those. It's a structured dialogue about one decision, in the tradition of Leonard Nelson and Gustav Heckmann. No slides, no models to learn. Anna facilitates and writes up; the group does the thinking.

Do we need to know any philosophy?

No. The only requirement is that someone in the room has concrete experience that bears on the decision. Everyone does.

Online or in the room?

Ninety minutes online works well for a steering group of four to eight. For a board, or a decision with more at stake, half a day in the room gives time for a second example and a proper test of the rule.

What if the decision falls apart in the session?

Then it would have fallen apart later, in delivery, at many times the cost. That outcome is the point, and the record says why.

Can I try the method first?

Yes. Decision Questions is a free tool that asks the same questions of a decision you describe. It's a good way to see whether the method suits your board.

Decisions that stand up to scrutiny

Book a 30-minute call