Skip to main content

Free tool

Decision Questions

Describe a decision your team or board is about to make. Get the questions a Socratic facilitator would ask before it's made, so it stands up in the room.

Free, no sign-upAbout a minuteBy Anna Bromley, programme director and trained Socratic Dialogue facilitator
Try an example:

We send what you write to Anthropic, our AI provider, to write the questions. We don't keep it. Leave out names and anything confidential.0/700

What kind of decision?

Who decides?

When?

The questions appear here

Six to eight of them, in the order a Socratic facilitator would ask: the real question, the example behind it, the reasons, the rule you're applying, and the principle underneath. Then the one to answer first.

  • The question. What are you really deciding, and what's assumed?
  • The example. What actually happened that makes you think this?
  • The reasons. When I saw X, I decided Y, because Z.
  • The rules. Would you decide the same way every time?
  • The principles. What do you value here, and what would you give up for it?

How the questions are chosen

A Socratic Dialogue is shaped like an hourglass. It starts wide with a question, narrows to one concrete example and the reasons behind it, then widens again to the rules and principles those reasons reveal. The tool asks in that order.

  1. 1

    The question

    What are you really deciding, and what's assumed?

  2. 2

    The example

    What actually happened that makes you think this?

  3. 3

    The reasons

    When I saw X, I decided Y, because Z.

  4. 4

    The rules

    Would you decide the same way every time?

  5. 5

    The principles

    What do you value here, and what would you give up for it?

Three rules carry it: use your own experience, not what you've read or heard; one thing at a time; and don't accept a judgement without examining it. Anna's handbook on the method, Time for Transformation, is on its way.

Frequently asked questions

What is a Socratic Dialogue?

A structured group conversation, in the tradition of Leonard Nelson and Gustav Heckmann, that answers one question by examining one concrete experience, then the reasons behind it, the rules those reasons imply and the principles underneath. Anna trained in it and runs dialogues alongside her programme work.

Does the tool tell me what to decide?

No. It only asks. The point is that a decision which can answer these questions is one you can defend. If several come back blank, that's the finding.

What happens to what I type?

It's sent to Anthropic, our AI provider, to write the questions, and shown back to you. We don't store it, log it or see it. Leave out names and anything confidential anyway.

Can you run this with our board?

Yes. A facilitated Decision Dialogue takes 90 minutes with the people who'll own the decision, and ends with the decision restated, the evidence you still need and what would change your mind. Book a call to talk it through.

Decisions that stand up to scrutiny

Book a 30-minute call